Stop Hoarding Your Retirement Money

‍ ‍

My grandmother used to say I was tight-fisted. She wasn't wrong. I have always been frugal — I will find a consignment shop before I pay full retail, I wait for sales like it is an Olympic sport, and I can stretch a dollar until it begs for mercy. I came by it honestly. I was a single parent raising two boys, and every dollar I spent on myself felt like a dollar I was taking from them.

But there was a moment — around 1995 — that I still think about. Alexander was about 14. Sinclair had just learned to walk. I was in a store called August Max with my youngest son's aunt, and I saw it: a cerulean blue sweater with silver buttons. Just beautiful. The kind of thing I would have walked past a hundred times and kept moving. But she encouraged me to buy it. For myself. Just for me. I paid for it. And then I stood right there in that store and cried. Not happy tears. Guilt. Pure, crushing guilt — because I had bought something for myself and not for my children. I had never done that before. Not once.

I am doing significantly better now than I was then. I can buy a quality pair of shoes when I need them — not Jimmy Choo, but something good and functional. And still. Still. There is a tightness in my chest every time I spend something on myself that isn't strictly necessary. I know I am not alone in that. Not even close.

So before we get to the numbers and the withdrawal strategies and the safe spending rates — I want to talk about why women hold on to their money the way we do. Because until we understand that, the math doesn't matter.

The Dirty Secret: Most Retirees Die With Too Much Money Left Over

This is not a math problem. The Employee Benefit Research Institute — one of the most serious retirement research organizations in the country — published a report in May 2026 showing that approximately one-third of retirees still have 100 percent or more of their starting retirement assets by the time they reach their mid-80s. Not half their money. Not a little bit. All of it. And more.

Researchers call it 'unnecessary underspending.' I call it unnecessary suffering. Because while these retirees were white-knuckling their savings accounts, they were also skipping the trip to see their grandkids. Putting off the knee surgery. Eating the same three meals on rotation because it felt safe. All while the account balance barely moved.

Here's what that tells us: A June 2024 study by researchers David Blanchett and Michael Finke — titled "Guaranteed Income: A License to Spend" — found that retirees with a guaranteed income stream, like a pension or annuity, spend twice as much as retirees with the same dollar amount sitting in a regular investment portfolio. Same money, totally different behavior. The difference is the permission that comes with knowing a check is coming no matter what.

The problem isn't the money. The problem is the mindset. And mindset — unlike a 401(k) balance — can actually be changed.

Why Women Hoard — And Why the Fear Is Completely Rational

‍Ask a woman why she is afraid to spend her retirement savings and she will probably say something practical. Inflation. Healthcare costs. Uncertainty. And those things are real. But underneath all of it — underneath the spreadsheets and the withdrawal rate calculations — there is usually one quieter, more honest fear: Who is going to save me if I run out?

‍Think about the women in your life. Not the ones in the financial planning commercials. The real ones. The ones who are single by choice or by circumstance. The ones who are widowed and suddenly managing money that was always handled by someone else. The ones who have a partner but know, deep in their gut, that they cannot count on that lasting or that being enough. There are millions of women living without a financial lifeline beyond what they built themselves. And for those women, holding tight is not irrational. It is survival logic.

‍The data confirms it. The EBRI's 2025 Retirement Confidence Survey found that women consistently report lower retirement confidence than men — not because they are less capable of managing money, but because they are far more likely to face retirement alone. Women outlive men by an average of nearly five years, according to the CDC. They are more likely to have taken career gaps for caregiving. They are more likely to still be supporting adult children or aging parents. And they have spent decades in a financial system that was not built for them. That history does not disappear when you retire. It shows up as guilt over a sweater.

‍So when I say stop hoarding your retirement money, I am not dismissing the fear. The fear makes complete sense. What I am saying is that hoarding without a plan does not actually protect you. It just means you suffer now and potentially still run short later. The antidote to fear is not spending recklessly. It is building a structure that tells you, with real numbers, exactly how much is safe to enjoy. And then enjoying it.

‍David Blanchett, head of retirement research at Prudential Financial, put it plainly: 'We train people to be ants.' Forty years of watching that quarterly statement grow. Forty years of save, save, save. And then one day, the rules are supposed to change — and nobody tells you how. For women who spent decades as their own safety net, that shift is not just difficult. It feels dangerous. And it takes more than a permission slip. It takes a plan.

‍ ‍

What “Running Out of Money” Actually Looks Like (It's Not What You Think)

Almost half of workers — 49 percent — believe they'll need more than a million dollars to retire comfortably, according to EBRI's 2024 Spending in Retirement Survey. But here's what's interesting: only 12 percent of people who are already retired feel that way. And a full one-third of retirees say they need less than $500,000 to cover their actual expenses. Once you're living it, it looks completely different.

‍The “running out of money” nightmare is real — but it's not evenly distributed. It tends to hit people who had no guaranteed income (no pension, no annuity), faced a major health crisis with no long-term care coverage, or retired into a down market in year one. Those are specific, addressable risks. They are not a reason to spend your retirement living like you're still saving for it.

‍Here's the practical frame: the 4 percent rule — the old standby for safe withdrawal rates — has been recalibrated. Morningstar's 2025 State of Retirement Income report puts the current safe starting withdrawal rate at 3.9 percent for a retiree seeking a 90 percent probability of not running out over a 30-year horizon. On a $200,000 portfolio, that's $7,800 a year — about $650 a month — from your savings alone. Add Social Security, a pension if you have one, and any part-time income, and the picture starts to look a lot less scary.

The terror of “running out” is real, but it's also been wildly overmarketed. The financial industry profits from your fear. Products get sold on it. Advisors get hired because of it. I'm not saying the fear is irrational — I'm saying it's been amplified past the point of usefulness, and it's costing you actual years of your actual life.

‍The Retirement Spending Curve: You'll Probably Spend Less Than You Think — Eventually

‍ Here's something the retirement brochures leave out: spending in retirement is not a flat line. It actually goes in phases. Early retirement — your 60s and early 70s — tends to be the most active and expensive. You're healthy, you're mobile, and you finally have the time to do things. This is go-go time. Spend the money.

‍Then comes the slow-go years — mid-70s and into the 80s — where travel gets harder and life naturally gets a little quieter. Spending often decreases on its own during this phase, not because you ran out but because your priorities shift. Finally, the no-go years — late 80s and beyond — where your biggest expense is likely healthcare and your lifestyle is simpler. This is when most people leave the largest amount unspent.

‍The tragedy of hoarding is this: you deprive yourself in the go-go years — the years when you can actually use and enjoy the money — because you're afraid of running out in the no-go years. And then the no-go years arrive and the money is still there. Sitting. Waiting. For what, exactly?

‍How to Build a Spending Plan That Doesn't Make You Lose Sleep

‍Okay, so we've established that the fear is real but overblown, that the data says most retirees die with money they never touched, and that your go-go years are finite and precious. Now what do you actually do?

‍Start with your non-negotiables. What does it cost every month to just live — housing, utilities, food, transportation, insurance, medications? Write it down. This is your floor. If your guaranteed income (Social Security plus any pension) covers your floor, everything else is yours to work with. That's the foundation of a no-panic retirement.

‍ Then identify your “joy spending.” What actually makes your life feel like yours? For some women, it's travel. For others, it's being the grandmother who can say yes — yes to the school trip, yes to the birthday party, yes to just buying something without calculating whether it's responsible. Whatever it is, put a number on it. Make it a line item. Give it the same respect you give your electric bill.

‍Finally, build your protection layer. This is your emergency fund — ideally 6 to 12 months of expenses sitting in something safe and accessible — and any plans you have for healthcare surprises or long-term care. Once that layer is in place, the rest of your money has a job: to fund the life you worked this hard to reach.

Five Signs You Might Be Underspending in Retirement

Check yourself before you wreck your retirement. Not sure if this is you? Here are some honest checkpoints.

1.  You still feel guilty spending money on yourself, even though you're no longer saving for the future.

2.  You say no to things you can actually afford — trips, experiences, gifts — out of habit, not necessity.

3.  Your savings account barely moves month to month because you're living on less than your income.

4.  You haven't updated your “what's enough” number since you were still working.

5.  You're still in accumulation mode mentally, even though the chapter is over.

If two or more of those hit, it's time for a real conversation — with yourself and possibly with a trusted financial advisor who actually listens. Not one who's trying to sell you something. One who's trying to help you live.

The Permission Slip Nobody Gave You

I want to say something clearly, because I don't think it gets said enough in the retirement space. You earned it. You sacrificed for it. You made hard choices and kept showing up even when it was hard. You did not do all of that so your account balance could look impressive in your estate documents. You did it so you could live.

And I say this knowing that for a lot of women — especially women who came up without a financial safety net, who were the safety net for everyone else — spending on yourself can feel deeply uncomfortable. Like it's selfish. Like something is going to go wrong the second you exhale. I know that feeling. It's not wisdom. It's an old survival habit that has outlived its usefulness.

Your retirement is not a holding pattern. It is not a waiting room. It is your life — the part you planned for, the part you earned, the part that belongs entirely to you. Spend it like you mean it.

‍ Frequently Asked Questions

Q: How do I know how much I can safely spend in retirement?

A: Start with your guaranteed income — Social Security, any pension, any annuity income. If that covers your basic expenses, you're in strong shape. For drawing from savings, a commonly used baseline is the 4 percent rule, though Morningstar's 2025 research puts the safest starting rate at 3.9 percent for a 30-year horizon. Run your actual numbers with the PROS™ Calculator at redefineyourretirement.com to see your real picture.

Q: What if I don't have a pension or guaranteed income — does that change things?

A: It changes the strategy, not the goal. Without guaranteed income, you'll want to be more deliberate about withdrawal sequencing (which accounts you draw from first) and consider whether a portion of your savings could be converted to a guaranteed income stream. A fee-only financial advisor can help you think through this without the conflict of interest that comes with commission-based advice.

Q: Is there a way to spend more early in retirement without running out later?

A: Yes — it's called a dynamic withdrawal strategy. Instead of withdrawing a fixed amount every year, you adjust based on market performance and your actual spending needs. In good years, you spend a bit more. In down years, you pull back. Research shows this approach can actually allow for higher lifetime spending than the rigid 4 percent rule.

Q: What about leaving money to my kids or grandkids?

A: Legacy planning is real and important, and there's nothing wrong with wanting to leave something behind. But the most valuable thing you can leave most families isn't a dollar amount — it's the example of a woman who lived fully and on her own terms. You can plan for both: a funded, joyful retirement and an intentional estate plan. They are not in competition.

Q: I'm not retired yet — does this apply to me?

A: Absolutely. The mindset shift from saver to spender doesn't happen automatically on the day you retire. Start practicing now by getting clear on what your retirement actually looks and feels like — not just the dollar number. The SMART Start™ tool at redefineyourretirement.com can help you build that vision before you get there.

Q: What if I genuinely don't have enough saved and I'm worried for real?

A: Then this article is still for you — because clarity is better than anxiety either way. Knowing your actual gap is the first step to addressing it, whether that means working a little longer, adding a part-time income stream in retirement, adjusting your lifestyle expectations, or maximizing your Social Security benefit by delaying it. Fear without a plan keeps you stuck. A plan — even an imperfect one — moves you forward.